Stanton Chase
How Do Executive Search Firms Differ From Recruitment Agencies

How Do Executive Search Firms Differ From Recruitment Agencies

May 2023


Video cover

Regular recruitment fills seats; executive recruitment builds empires.

When a business needs to hire an executive, it has two options: conducting an internal search using its own networks and processes or seeking external assistance from either an executive search firm or a recruiting agency.

According to a survey conducted by Stanton Chase Belgrade, which interviewed general and human resources (HR) directors, the decision to hire an executive search company or a recruitment agency is primarily made by the following departments:

  • Top management (42.4%)
  • Human resources department (39.4%)

In terms of decision-making processes, the survey found the following:

  • Tender process: 21.2% of companies make the decision through a tender process.
  • Global or regional agreements: An equal percentage (21.2%) of companies engage in such partnerships with executive search firms or recruiting agencies as part of global or regional agreements.
  • Company headquarters: The decision is made by the company headquarters in 18.2% of cases.
  • Recommendations from business partners: Recommendations from business partners account for 12.1% of cases.

The most important service offered by executive search companies, as perceived by general and HR managers, is the identification of individuals for senior management positions. Following that, the assessment of existing management staff ranks as the second most important service. Coaching for managers and proposals for human resource development strategies follow thereafter.

This white paper aims to explore the key differences between executive search firms and recruiting agencies.

What is the Definition of an Executive Search Firm vs. a Recruiting Agency?

Executive search firms serve as trusted advisors, comprised of consultants with extensive experience in leadership consulting across various industries. These consultants often have backgrounds as senior executives, business founders, or board members, and may hold impressive degrees. Their expertise lies in identifying, evaluating, assessing, and selecting the best person for a job, with their success measured by the positive impact their candidates bring to the companies they join.

Recruiting agencies, on the other hand, provide a pool of candidates that meet specific requirements but typically lack the same level of management experience as executive search consultants. Focusing on quantity over quality, the responsibility of assessing and selecting the right candidate ultimately falls on the client. As a result, they may not fully understand the intricacies of your business or the role their candidates can play in driving it forward.

What is the Difference Between the Executive Search Business Model and the Business Model of Ordinary Recruiters?

Executive search firms specialize in personalized, client-centric services that align with specific project requirements. They gain a deep understanding of their clients’ needs and have access to passive candidates. They are involved in every aspect of the hiring process, prioritize high-quality service, present well-qualified candidates, and establish long-term, trust-based relationships. Their fees reflect their comprehensive advisory work. Their income is generated through successful placements and strong reputations.

Recruiting agents focus on placing numerous candidates quickly, handling multiple assignments simultaneously, and lacking a deep understanding of their clients’ businesses. They provide their services without upfront fees, receiving payment only when candidates they recommend are hired. Their income is directly tied to the speed and volume of candidate placements.

What is the Difference Between Executive Search Firms’ Methodology and That of Ordinary Recruiters?

Executive search consultants spearhead projects by thoroughly grasping their client’s industry, business strategy, and distinct requirements. They utilize advanced techniques like competency-based interviews, 360-degree evaluations, and due diligence procedures to pinpoint the most suitable candidates. Their success is measured by the long-lasting commitment and impact of the hired individual.

Recruiting agents capitalize on advertising and online databases to gather a vast array of candidate resumes. These resumes are forwarded to clients for further consideration and independent evaluation. Owing to their “payment upon placement” business model, they strive to present as many resumes as possible to numerous clients in the shortest amount of time.

What Type of Candidates Do Executive Search Firms Find vs. Recruiting Agencies?

Executive search firms primarily focus on filling executive roles and board director positions, locating exceptional candidates who may not be actively seeking a job change, and whose success or failure will significantly impact the company.

Recruiting agencies are commonly utilized for lower or mid-level positions with numerous qualified candidates. They seek out candidates actively pursuing new opportunities and fill positions that have a lesser impact on the client organization.

What is the Candidate Perspective of Executive Search Firms vs. Recruiting Agencies?

Executive search consultants engage with senior executives who might not be actively pursuing a new position, handling their potential interest with utmost confidentiality, and assisting them in recognizing potential benefits of transitioning for the right opportunity.

Recruiting agents connect with candidates inclined to be in lower or mid-level roles, who are actively seeking a new position. They possess a robust sales orientation and concentrate on collaborating with numerous clients and candidates, which can be advantageous for lower or mid-level candidates aiming to make a move.

Is an Executive Search Firm the Right Fit for You?

Executive search firms belonging to the Association of Executive Search Consultants (AESC) uphold the highest international standards, ensuring a solid commitment to clients, cultivating partnerships built on mutual respect and trust, and acting as business advisors.

These firms offer distinct advantages over recruitment agencies, such as a profound understanding of clients’ unique needs, expertise in sourcing leadership professionals, comprehensive consultant experience, and confidentiality. Additionally, they are recognized for their modern candidate assessments, their ability to find compatible candidates who can bring about real change, their ability to meet pre-agreed deadlines, and the business growth, increased market share, and increased revenue their candidates bring about.

Executive search firms further stand out in their communication with clients and candidates, as well as their industry-specific consultant specializations. A well-defined standardization of procedures further sets them apart.

Connect with a Visionary Executive Search Firm — Connect with Stanton Chase

At Stanton Chase, our 30-year track record demonstrates our commitment to helping some of the world’s most prominent and successful companies find the exceptional leaders they need to excel. Whether you require a visionary Chief Executive Officer with the tenacity to enact real change and disrupt your industry, or a Chief Human Resources Officer with a compassionate heart to champion diversity, equity, inclusion, belonging, and mental health initiatives, we’re here to assist.

What distinguishes Stanton Chase from other executive search firms? Our fearless ambition and tailored approach. We’re unafraid to be disruptors while maintaining a personable and humanistic approach. By understanding our clients as individuals, including their unique fears, aspirations, and objectives, we’re better equipped to help their businesses thrive.

If you’re seeking the kind of corporate leadership that can turn your dreams into reality, click here to connect with one of our executive search consultants.

“It doesn’t make sense to hire smart people and tell them what to do. We hire smart people so they can tell us what to do.” — Steve Jobs

About the Author

Milos Tucakovic is a Managing Partner at Stanton Chase Belgrade. He is also Stanton Chase’s Consumer Products and Services Global Practice Leader.

Milos has almost two decades of executive search and leadership advisory experience, and prior to this accumulated nearly 30 years of human resources and management experience.

Milos is a member of the Serbian Association of Managers and Knowledge Committee of Serbia. He also lectures on management at the College of Hotel Management in Belgrade.

Executive Search
Board Governance

How Can We Help?

At Stanton Chase, we're more than just an executive search and leadership consulting firm. We're your partner in leadership.

Our approach is different. We believe in customized and personal executive search, executive assessment, board services, succession planning, and leadership onboarding support.

We believe in your potential to achieve greatness and we'll do everything we can to help you get there.

View All Services